Would you do this trade?

I would hold on to Weaver. As good as Votto is, you could always find a hot 1B to replace him on the waiver wire if need be. Obviously, almost no one will be able to replace Votto's production, but Jared Weaver is the best pitcher in baseball at this moment and I wouldn't trade him for anything. Good pitching is far more valuable than good batting not just in real life, but in fantasy too. Plus, Morneau seems to be getting back into the swing of things. He's a step down from Votto, but I'd rather keep Weaver and have Morneau as your 1B than trade Weaver and only have Votto at 1B. Just my opinion.